Enriquez is an actress and singer who has appeared in the television series This was one of Jeter's longer relationships, lasting from 1996-1998 with the diva.
Jeter and Carey were the first high-profile pairing in a train of many for Jeter.
At the time Minnillo was hosting MTV's "Total Request Live" and was a former Miss Teen USA.
Find out who Derek Jeter hit home runs with off the field!
After all, Tuesday night marked the 14th All-Star appearance from a player with five World Series rings. As much a Jeter is known as one of the most respected and professional athletes in the world of sports, he is famously known for being private as well.